Look Familiar? Apple's IPod and Mini Designs 'Inspire' Other Makers

Look-alikes for Apple's music players and tiny desktop show up at Computex trade show.

Martyn Williams, IDG News Service

TAIPEI-- If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, Apple Computer executives at the Computex show in Taipei this week should be feeling pretty good. A clutch of products were on display from local Taiwanese vendors that, while perhaps not exact copies of Apple products, were surely inspired by them.

AOpen's unnamed tiny PC.

One of the highest-profile of these look-alikes was a small desktop PC from AOpen. The computer was on show at the booths of both AOpen and Intel as part of an Intel effort to promote the use of the Pentium M processor in small PCs, although the version on show was based on a Celeron M processor.

The machine, which didn't have a name, was almost identical in size to Apple's Mac Mini, and had the same shape and a CD slot in the front of the machine. It's the result of about two months of engineering and design work by the company, said Gavin Lin, a senior director with AOpen's mainboard and platform business division. The company said it hopes to put the machine on sale in September this year.

Tekram Systems' IPocket MP3 players.

Among the personal audio players on display, several devices bore a resemblance to Apple's hit IPod products. Two of the closest, at least to an untrained eye, were Tekram Systems' IPocket and Luxpro's Tangent line of players.

Looking much like an IPod Mini, but with the addition of four buttons under the display, the IPocket doesn't contain any memory; instead, it has a slot on the base that accepts Secure Digital (SD), MultiMediaCard (MMC), and Memory Stick cards. It plays MP3, Windows Media Audio, WAV, ASF, and AAC audio files.

"You're not from Apple are you?" asked Charlie Chen, a sales specialist at Tekram, when a reporter asked to take a photo of the IPocket. "Apple's lawyers came to us at CeBIT," he said, referring to the German electronics fair that took place in March this year. "They said it's a nice design but don't try to sell it in the United States."

Tekram sells the IPocket in eastern Europe and parts of the Middle East, South America, and Asia, but isn't going to sell it in the United States or western Europe, Chen said.

On a Tangent

The Luxpro Tangent players come in three models, two of which were shown for the first time at Computex. All three are small, thin, and rectangular with rounded corners. The navigation controls are arranged in a circle on the front, with settings switches on the reverse. A cap covers the USB (Universal Serial Bus) connector.

Company representatives at Luxpro's booth said they weren't sure where the basic design idea for the players came from, but most people stopping for a look over a 5-minute period remarked that the devices appeared quite similar to the IPod Shuffle.

Luxpro Tangent's MP3 players.

Although the two new models have OLED (organic light emitting diode) screens, in contrast to Apple's display-less Shuffle, the resemblance is still there, at least according to comments overheard at the company's booth.

The Shuffle's clean design provided some inspiration for Jetway Information's IVogue M2 portable music player, said Richard Terng, associate vice president of Asia-Pacific sales at the Taipei company.

"We tried to do something similar," he said. The resulting product is roughly the same size and shape as the IPod Shuffle, but it has a rectangular control panel and a display. The device is compatible with MP3, Windows Media Audio, and WAV files and is available in 256MB, 512MB, or 1GB versions, said Terng.

Sumner Lemon of IDG News Service contributed to this story.

For more coverage of Asia's largest technology show, see PC World's Computex news page.