W3C: Redesigning the Internet

Researchers say semantic Web will determine the future of the Internet.

Jeremy Kirk, IDG News Service

EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND-- Hundreds of researchers and computer scientists are plotting the Internet's next course in Edinburgh, Scotland this week, pouring over research papers and discussing ideas that include how to organize the growing mass of data on the Web.

Much of the discussion is centered on the "semantic Web," the term for how researchers believe information on the Web can be intelligently labeled, interpreted, and linked through applications that can draw relationships and discover buried information.

Computer scientists have grand visions for how the semantic Web will help users cut to the core information they are seeking. A few years ago, attaching keywords to Web pages was seen as the way to make orderly sense of data, but that is now increasingly viewed as inferior.

However, there is trepidation as to how this next version of the Internet will develop, and if the new ideas can be translated into applications and interfaces that are easy for users.

"I think there's a chance actually that we can do better this time around," said Tim Berners-Lee, who is credited with inventing the World Wide Web in 1989. He was one of several panelists in a discussion about the semantic Web on Wednesday at the W3C (World Wide Web) conference here.

"I think it's also possible we mess that up, and the Web 2.0 becomes a big mess of rather unreliable stuff which you end up having to go through with Google," he said.

Redesigning the Web

Google PageRank feature was seen as a leap forward in search, but computer scientists are striving for far more advanced tools. The dawn of a semantic Web will not replace search engines, and the technology is seen as being complementary to other applications that will mine the data attached to Web pages.

Search engines may eventually be able to use pages optimized for semantic Web content, although Berners-Lee jokingly predicted that search companies won't be overly enthusiastic about the concept.

"Search engines make their money by making order of chaos," Berners-Lee said. "If you gave them order, then they wouldn't have a business. So that's why they are not interested in looking at the semantic Web."

Labeling information on the Internet involves tagging it with code and then classifying it into a taxonomy. Customized taxonomies and ontologies, or data models, could be created for different subject matters to connect disparate, rich information tucked away on servers.

It's an approach that differs vastly from current search engine technology, which may be able to find all instances of a keyword and rank a document's popularity but not interpret the context.

"Google is great, but I don't want go look up Exxon Mobile on Google and get 6 million hits," said Clare Hart, executive vice president at Dow Jones and chairman of Factiva, the company's subscription news aggregation service. "It doesn't help me if the meaningful hit is 20 links down."

A Hard Sell

The semantic Web concept can be applied to data held within enterprises. But businesses are concerned with how to label their data and ultimately their return on investment in semantic technologies.

In the long term, businesses need to realize that developing ontologies for data is an asset, said Richard Benjamins, director of innovation and research and development at Intelligent Software Components in Madrid.

Before semantic technology will progress, businesses will have to be convinced that ontologies are manageable and affordable. "That perception does not exist yet," he said.

But cost of hunting for data is high, since it's not an efficient use of people's time, Hart said.

"What's unfortunate is the amount of time people are spending searching is increasing," she said. "The semantic Web is going to enable that to decrease, and that's I think the return on investment companies have to strive for."